Custom birthday cakes, ordered a week ahead

We bake cakes the same way we bake bread: in small numbers, by hand, on a schedule we can actually keep. Tell us the date seven days out and we'll have it boxed and cold at pickup.

Start a cake order See sizes and pricing

A two-layer birthday cake finished in swirled buttercream with fresh berries on top

How ordering works, step by step

Five steps, start to finish. Most of them take you about two minutes.

  • 1. Send the form

    Fill out the order form at the bottom of this page. Date, size, cake flavor, filling, and whatever writing you want piped on top. If you're not sure on one of them, say so and we'll ask.

  • 2. We reply within one business day

    Lena or Marcus writes back from hello@goldencrumbfrisco.com confirming we have the date open, the final price, and the pickup window. If we're full that weekend we'll tell you straight away rather than leave you waiting.

  • 3. You pay the deposit

    Half down to hold the date. Pay at the counter or over the phone at (214) 555-0138. The date isn't yours until the deposit lands — we've learned that one the hard way.

  • 4. We bake two days out

    Layers go in the oven 48 hours before pickup, chill overnight, get filled and iced the morning before. Buttercream tastes best when it hasn't been sitting in a cooler for a week.

  • 5. You pick it up

    Come to the counter in your window, pay the balance, and we'll carry it to your car. Keep it flat on the floorboard, not the seat. Seatbelts don't hold cake boxes.

Sizes, servings, and pricing

Every cake is two layers with filling between, iced all over. Serving counts assume a normal birthday slice — about an inch and a half wide. If your crowd goes back for seconds, size up.

6-inch round
8 to 10 servings · $48. Good for a small family table or an office of six.
8-inch round
14 to 18 servings · $68. Our most-ordered size by a wide margin.
10-inch round
24 to 30 servings · $94. The one for a backyard party.
Quarter sheet
20 to 24 servings · $78. Flat top, easy to write on, easy to cut.
Half sheet
40 to 48 servings · $140. Our largest. We don't go bigger than this.
Six cupcakes
$18 per half dozen. Same batters, same buttercream, minimum one dozen on a custom order.

Prices include filling, icing, and piped writing. Fresh berries on top add $8 on a round and $14 on a sheet, and we only use them when the berries at market are worth it. Texas sales tax is added at pickup.

Cake and filling flavors

Pick one cake and one filling. That's the whole menu — we'd rather do nine things properly than thirty things halfway.

Cakes

  • Vanilla butter cake

    Creamed butter, whole eggs, buttermilk, and real vanilla bean paste. Tight, tender crumb. The safe answer that nobody is ever disappointed by.

  • Dark chocolate

    Dutch cocoa bloomed in hot coffee, so it tastes like chocolate rather than sweet brown. Moist enough to hold two days.

  • Brown butter spice

    Cinnamon, a little clove, brown butter cooked until it smells like toffee. Our fall favorite, available all year.

  • Lemon cornmeal

    Fine stone-ground cornmeal for a slight grit, a lot of zest, a soak of lemon syrup while warm. Lighter than it sounds.

  • Confetti

    The vanilla butter cake with sprinkles folded through. Ordered almost exclusively for children, eaten almost exclusively by adults.

Fillings and icings

  • Vanilla Swiss buttercream

    Egg whites and sugar cooked over water, whipped, then a pound of butter beaten in. Silky, not gritty, not tooth-achingly sweet.

  • Chocolate buttercream

    The same base with melted 64% chocolate folded in. Darker in color and flavor than the grocery-store kind.

  • Cream cheese icing

    Tangy, soft, a little looser. Lovely on the spice cake. Needs to stay cold until an hour before you cut it.

  • Strawberry jam

    Cooked down in our own kitchen, seeds and all. Between the layers only, with buttercream on the outside.

  • Salted caramel

    Sugar taken dark, cream, flaky salt. Between the layers with chocolate or vanilla buttercream outside. Add $6.

Allergens: every cake contains wheat, dairy, and egg. Our kitchen also handles tree nuts, peanuts, sesame, and poppy seed daily. We cannot promise an allergen-free cake and we won't pretend otherwise.

Decoration styles we do well — and what we don't do

We're bakers before we're decorators. Here's an honest line between the two.

Yes, gladly

  • Swirled buttercream

    Spatula-swept sides, a soft wave across the top. Our house finish and the one in the photograph above.

  • Smooth sides, piped border

    Clean bench-scraped buttercream with a shell or rope border top and bottom. Tidy without looking fussy.

  • Piped writing

    Up to about six words on a round, ten on a sheet. We pipe in a plain hand, in white, dark chocolate, or one tinted color.

  • Fresh fruit and flowers

    Berries, figs, citrus segments, or food-safe unsprayed blooms from a Frisco grower. Seasonal, so ask what's good that week.

  • Sprinkles and a candle count

    A sprinkle border, a crown of them, whatever the birthday kid wants. Candles included free, just tell us the number.

  • One tinted color

    We'll tint buttercream to a soft shade — dusty pink, sage, pale blue. Deep reds and blacks take so much dye they taste bitter, so we keep it gentle.

No, sorry

  • Fondant

    We don't roll it, drape it, or model it. It looks sharp and tastes like sweet plastic, and that isn't a trade we want to make.

  • Sculpted and tiered cakes

    No carved guitars, no dinosaurs, no stacked tiers with dowels. That's a different craft and other shops in town do it better.

  • Printed photo toppers

    We don't have the printer and we're not getting one. You're welcome to bring your own topper and we'll set it on at pickup.

  • Licensed characters

    We don't copy cartoon characters or logos. A sprinkle color scheme in their colors, though — that we can do, and kids are happy with it.

Lead times, deposits, and pickup windows

Standard notice
Seven full days before pickup. A form sent Tuesday morning gets a cake the following Tuesday or later.
Busy dates
Mother's Day weekend, graduation weekends in late May, and the week of Thanksgiving fill a month out. Ask early.
Short notice
Call and ask. If we have a slot and the flavors on hand we'll sometimes manage four days. Never same-day.
Deposit
50% to hold the date, paid at the counter or by card over the phone. Balance due at pickup.
Changes
Flavor, writing, and size can change up to 72 hours before pickup. After that the layers are baked.
Cancellations
Full refund more than 72 hours out. Inside 72 hours the deposit covers the ingredients already bought.
Pickup windows
Tuesday to Friday, 9am–5pm. Saturday 8am–3pm. Closed Sunday and Monday, so no Sunday-morning pickups.
Holding the cake
We'll keep it cold up to 24 hours past your window. After that we can't promise the buttercream stays sharp.

Getting it home

Flat on the car floor, air conditioning on, straight home. Keep it in the fridge in its box and pull it out an hour before you cut — cold buttercream is firm and dull, and room-temperature buttercream is the whole point.

I ordered an 8-inch lemon cornmeal with strawberry jam for my dad's seventieth. They wrote back the next morning with the exact price, no upsell, and the thing was waiting cold on the counter at nine on Saturday. He ate two slices standing up.

Priya R., Frisco

Start a cake order

Tell us the date first — everything else we can sort out by email. If you don't know a flavor yet, leave it and say so in the notes. We read every one of these ourselves and reply within one business day, Tuesday through Saturday.

Prefer to talk it through? Call (214) 555-0138 during opening hours, or come stand at the counter — we'd rather that anyway.